What Buyers Need to Know About Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuities Before Chasing High Rates
Multi-year guaranteed annuities (MYGAs) offer conservative savers predictable returns over typical terms of three, five, or seven years with tax-deferred growth, but annuity researcher Sheryl J. Moore warns that an advertised rate alone does not make a contract a good deal.
In an interview with TheStreet, the Wink Inc. CEO outlined key risks and features buyers should evaluate before committing retirement savings:
- Insurer financial strength: Because annuities are not backed by the U.S. government and state guaranty protections—typically up to $250,000—can involve complex insolvency proceedings, buyers should evaluate claims-paying ability using ratings from Fitch, Moody’s, and S&P rather than simply choosing a newer insurer offering a 1% higher rate.
- Liquidity and surrender rules: Unlike bank certificates of deposit, MYGAs lock up principal for the full contract term, typically allowing penalty-free withdrawals of only 5% to 10% per year after the first year.
- Bonuses and renewals: Contracts offering first-year rate bonuses often credit lower base rates than comparable non-bonus products, and insurers frequently offer better rates to new clients than to existing policyholders renewing at term end.
- Private equity ownership: Insurers backed by private equity firms often offer more competitive rates by investing premiums in higher-yielding, riskier assets, requiring buyers to assess the insurer's underlying investments.
Moore noted that MYGAs are best suited for risk-averse savers looking for CD-like guarantees, rather than active investors seeking higher market upside.